Reader Kelsey wrote in to ask for advice on an outfit for her 3-year anniversary that would compliment her size-12 figure. We chose a silver satin Chloe and Reese dress with some accessories that pop. The dress’s high waistline, wide neckline, demure yet sexy length, and wide straps that allow for a bra will all do Kelsey justice. Along with the silver dress we chose BCBGirls rhinestone slingbacks because many of us already have a similar pair in our closet, and if you don’t, at $66, these will be a workhorse for your dressy wardrobe. Read on for more info on the rest of the dazzling accessories.

We really went for broke and chose these fantasy Tiffany rubellite drop earrings, $29,500. We allowed such a pricy item because they’re so fun, but should also be very easy to find a cheap copy of at nearly any department store. And to pick up on the fabulous color of the jewelry, we went with this Blulu red fabric clutch from Steve Madden, on sale for $38.