Archive for the ‘Yay or Nay’ Category

Accessories, Footwear, Yay or Nay

Yay or Nay Wednesday: Acne Iman Platform Oxford Pump

By Andrea Kiliany Thatcher on May 7th, 2008

Acne pump.jpg

These distressed suede lace-up bootie pumps have a lot going on. The Acne Jeans Iman Platform Oxford Pump, $519, teeter on a 4.25″ suede-covered heel with 0.88″ platform.

The ultimate in unique luxe? Or, like acne itself, something you could really live without? Leave your yay or nay vote in the comments below.



Footwear, Yay or Nay

Yay or Nay Wednesday: Givenchy jellies?

By Andrea Kiliany Thatcher on April 23rd, 2008

Givenchy jellies copy.jpg

Do our eyes deceive? Givenchy is making jelly shoes?

It’s true. The Givenchy jelly gladiator, $165, comes in pink and black with adjustable ankle straps.

What do you think? Nostalgic throwback great for the beach, or sweaty sandal that should stay in the sandbox? Yay or Nay?



Celebrity Style, Red Carpet, Yay or Nay, dresses

Yay or Nay Wednesday: Parker Posey at Smart People premiere

By Andrea Kiliany Thatcher on April 2nd, 2008

Parker Posey copy.jpg

We don’t usually feature people for Yay or Nay here at ShinyStyle, it seems mean. But our love for Parker Posey is such that we hope it evens out any ill-will toward this outfit. You know, in terms of fashion karma.

Read the rest of this entry »



Yay or Nay

Yay or Nay Wednesday: overalls

By Andrea Kiliany Thatcher on March 26th, 2008

trouser overalls.jpg

Overalls are a joke, right? They look more ridiculous in old TLC videos than the “birth control” sunglasses do, and poor Jillian was caught wearing them just a couple months ago on Project Runway. So if they’re so ridiculous why do people keep making them?

Read the rest of this entry »



Accessories, Designer Fashions, Yay or Nay

Yay or Nay Wednesday: Burberry Prorsum Harlech studded belt

By Andrea Kiliany Thatcher on March 19th, 2008

Burberry belt.jpg

Is it a medieval torture device or a belt? Depends how tight you cinch it we supposed.

The real question is: Yay or Nay?

To be fair we’ll show you what it looks like as part of an outfit after the jump.

Read the rest of this entry »



Accessories, Designer Fashions, Footwear, New Fashions, Yay or Nay

Yay or Nay Wednesday: Christian Louboutin cutout bootie

By Andrea Kiliany Thatcher on March 12th, 2008

Louboutin cutout bootie.jpg

For many of us, booties themselves were questionable enough. So what do you think of this Christian Louboutin cutout bootie, $860?

And furthermore, when you see a shoe or bag or any item that you’re not sure about – does it help sway you when it’s by a favorite designer?

Would you buy a shoe by Christian Louboutin that you would never buy from a less iconic designer? Why?



Accessories, Designer Fashions, Handbags, New Fashions, Yay or Nay

Yay or Nay Wednesday: Marc Jacobs mesh lace Robert bag on bags

By Andrea Thatcher on February 13th, 2008

Marc%20Jacobs%20bag%20on%20bag.jpg

Keris over at TheBagLady drew our attention to this Marc Jacobs bag-on-bag combo, $2,100. What do we think, yay or nay? I believe this raises a larger fashion philosophical question – does the fact that it’s Marc Jacobs ensure that it’s a yay? After his spring collection, some people are changing their tunes on that issue. What about you? Little purse sewed onto a big purse – yay or nay?



Accessories, Designer Fashions, Handbags, New Fashions, Retail News, Yay or Nay

Yay or Nay Wednesday: new Chloe bags

By Andrea Thatcher on January 30th, 2008

new%20chloe%20bags.jpg (Click image to enlarge.)

What do you think of the new Chloe bags just arrived at Net-a-Porter? Personally, these bags make me long for an Elvire or the days of the Paddington. From left to right we have the Ada tote, $2,280, the bay bag, a favorite of our UK sister TheBagLady at $1,780, and the Saskia leather tote, $,2005, my least favorite of the bunch. What do you think – yay or nay?

For more handbag news, go to www.thebaglady.tv.



Celebrity Style, Yay or Nay

Yay or Nay Wednesday: Mena Suvari at Sundance

By Andrea Thatcher on January 23rd, 2008

Mena%20Suvari%20Sundance.jpg

What do you think of Mena Suvari’s look in the famous photobooth at the Sundance Film Festival? We find it interesting to wear when you know you’re not only going to be shot by paparazzi, but are having your cast portraits taken that day (she’s in The Mysteries of Pittsburgh). I would probably warm up to the whole look, even if it is a bit tough, if only she weren’t wearing that head scarf. I think it’s aweful, but some have said it made the outfit. What do you think?



Accessories, Designer Fashions, Handbags, High End Department Stores, Yay or Nay

Yay or Nay Wednesday: Gucci Joy Boston Bag

By Andrea Thatcher on January 16th, 2008

Gucci%20joy%20bag.jpg

When we were perusing the new spring/summer Gucci arrivals at Saks Fifth Avenue, we really liked this Gucci Joy Boston bag in the thumbnail and so clicked on it. But when we got up close, we weren’t so sure. Is the floral embroidery that looks more like applique in some parts, too much or just enough? Or does the basic black and white palette make up for it? If you had the $1,950 lying around, would you buy this bag, yay or nay?



Accessories, Designer Fashions, Footwear, New Fashions, Yay or Nay

Yay or Nay Wednesday: Balenciaga Derby shearling high heels

By Andrea Thatcher on January 2nd, 2008

Balenciaga%20bootie.jpg

So we know it’s us, and not Nicolas Ghesquiere, but we’re not totally getting Balenciaga’s shoes as of late. These derby shearling high heels for instance, when we think of them in terms of Carrie wearing something like them in a fictional Sex and the City world we get it. But then we think about the real world we live in, and we don’t. Do you? Yay or Nay?



Designer Fashions, Yay or Nay, outerwear

Yay or Nay Wednesday: Chloe tie-front raincoat

By Andrea Thatcher on December 19th, 2007

Chloe%20pink%20jacket.jpg

I know it’s Chloe, and we feel bad putting anything of hers in the Yay or Nay category…but it’s pink vinyl. This $1,970 tie-front coat looks a little bit like a raincoat I had in kindergarten, and also one my Barbie had. Which I thought was fabulous at the time, but all grown up … I don’t know. What do you think?



Accessories, Handbags, Yay or Nay

Yay or Nay Wednesday: floral vinyl tote from Forever 21

By Andrea Thatcher on December 12th, 2007

floral%20vinyl%20tote.jpg

This floral vinyl tote with braided rope drawstring and handles is $28.80 at Forever 21. What do you think? Is is trend-right for spring with the floral motif, or does it kind of look like one of those “designer trash bags” that have prints on them? Yay or Nay?



Accessories, Designer Fashions, High End Department Stores, New Fashions, Yay or Nay

Yay or Nay Wednesday: Earmuffs

By Andrea Thatcher on November 28th, 2007

Burberry%20earmuffs.jpg

These just in: bordeaux quilted patent leather ear muffs from Burberry. Now there’s no question, if you’re going to wear ear muffs, these are the most fabulous ones to sport – but would you wear ear muffs? If you live somewhere like Georgia and don’t really have a winter, you might not even be able to contemplate such an accessory, but in colder climes it’s often tempting to wrap your entire head in a wool scarf just to get the mail. So, would you wear ear muffs?



Footwear, Yay or Nay

Open-toe boot: Yay or Nay?

By Andrea Thatcher on November 21st, 2007

opentoeboot.jpgOk, so I love knee-high boots and I love open-toe shoes, but together? I’m not so sure. These Open-toe Boots from Arden B. combine both my loves for a look I can only deem as overkill. I like the way these nylon knee-high boots fit very snug against the leg, and they’d look great with a slightly rounded toe, but the open toe just looks odd. It kind of defeats the purpose of a boot, don’t you think? They’re for keeping your feet warm on chilly days while still creating a sexy, stylish look, so we don’t lament the wonderful sandal-wearing days of summer so much… But that’s just my opinion, what do you think?




©2010 Shiny Digital Privacy Policy