Archive for the ‘Yay or Nay’ Category

Gossip Girl, Yay or Nay

Yay or Nay Wednesday: A Blair fashion misstep?

By Andrea Kiliany Thatcher on August 20th, 2008

Leighton Meester copy.jpg

We know a lot of you are in the Blair can do no fashion wrong camp, and believe us, our tent is firmly staked. But…

Are we out of line to say that this mixed print outfit on Leighton Meester from the Gossip Girl set is a little iffy? We’re not sure if the matchy-matchy colors make it better or worse.

Yay or Nay? Send your comments to andrea@shinymedia.com.

[Image: Humberto Carreno/Rex Features]



Swimwear, Yay or Nay

Yay or Nay Wednesday: cut out swimsuits

By Andrea Thatcher on July 9th, 2008

cutout swimsuits.jpg

Swimsuits with extreme cutouts of nearly every configuration are a big trend this summer.

But it seems to us like if you want to show off a lot of skin, bikinis are often more flattering and functional.

This spotty one piece from Topshop (can’t wait till you get to NYC Topshop, kiss kiss!) is a good example of what we’re talking about. It’s basically a bikini with a long strip attaching the two pieces.

If you’re used to one pieces, do cutout suits make you more comfortable than a bikini? Or if you’re a bikini bunny, would you try one of these instead? Tell us in the comments below.



shoes, Yay or Nay

Yay or Nay Wednesday: Donna Karan velvet sandal

By Andrea Kiliany Thatcher on June 25th, 2008

Donna Karan shoe.jpg

This Donna Karan velvet and silk macramé evening sandal certainly is a work of art. But is it a work of art you want to wear on your foot?

From the fall 2008 ready to wear accessories collection, this statement shoe would surely overpower anything else you were wearing – which can be good or bad.

The yellowy-green-gray color palette throws an extra twist into an already twisty and turny design. What do you think, yay or nay?



Celebrity Style, Yay or Nay

Yay or Nay Wednesday: Marisa Tomei at the Tony Awards

By Andrea Kiliany Thatcher on June 18th, 2008

Marisa Tomei copy.jpg

Marisa Tomei has always had a somewhat questionable style sense. Combine that with the fact that she was attending the 62nd Annual Tony Awards, an event a bit more formal and dare we say less fashionable than most red carpet award shows, and it’s a recipe for … a dress like this.

The belt, the flower appliques, the chiffonish train … is it all too much? Yay or Nay? Tell us in the comments below.

[Image: Sara Jaye/Rex Features]

Related: Yay or Nay Wednesday: Lily Allen at the Glamour Woman of the Year awards



Celebrity Style, Yay or Nay

Yay or Nay Wednesday: Lily Allen at the Glamour Woman of the Year awards

By Andrea Thatcher on June 4th, 2008

lilly allen copy.jpg

While we’re all for Lily Allen’s Editor’s Special Award at the Glamour Woman of the Year Awards, but we’re not so sure about her Giles Deacon spring ’08 deer print dress … or the shoes … or the hair.

What do you think? Does she pull of the punk bridal look, yay or nay?



Accessories, Handbags, Yay or Nay

Yay or Nay Wednesday: Chloe Saskia patchwork pouchette

By Andrea Kiliany Thatcher on May 28th, 2008

Chloe bag.jpg

We’re big fans of the Chloe Saskia shoulder bags, but we’re not sure sure about this patchwork version.

Sure, it seems Kate Bosworth is a fan, but what about you?

Yay or nay for the Chloe Saskia patchwork pouchette, $1,560?



Accessories, Footwear, Yay or Nay

Yay or Nay Wednesday: Acne Iman Platform Oxford Pump

By Andrea Kiliany Thatcher on May 7th, 2008

Acne pump.jpg

These distressed suede lace-up bootie pumps have a lot going on. The Acne Jeans Iman Platform Oxford Pump, $519, teeter on a 4.25″ suede-covered heel with 0.88″ platform.

The ultimate in unique luxe? Or, like acne itself, something you could really live without? Leave your yay or nay vote in the comments below.



Footwear, Yay or Nay

Yay or Nay Wednesday: Givenchy jellies?

By Andrea Kiliany Thatcher on April 23rd, 2008

Givenchy jellies copy.jpg

Do our eyes deceive? Givenchy is making jelly shoes?

It’s true. The Givenchy jelly gladiator, $165, comes in pink and black with adjustable ankle straps.

What do you think? Nostalgic throwback great for the beach, or sweaty sandal that should stay in the sandbox? Yay or Nay?



Celebrity Style, dresses, Red Carpet, Yay or Nay

Yay or Nay Wednesday: Parker Posey at Smart People premiere

By Andrea Kiliany Thatcher on April 2nd, 2008

Parker Posey copy.jpg

We don’t usually feature people for Yay or Nay here at ShinyStyle, it seems mean. But our love for Parker Posey is such that we hope it evens out any ill-will toward this outfit. You know, in terms of fashion karma.

Read the rest of this entry »



Yay or Nay

Yay or Nay Wednesday: overalls

By Andrea Kiliany Thatcher on March 26th, 2008

trouser overalls.jpg

Overalls are a joke, right? They look more ridiculous in old TLC videos than the “birth control” sunglasses do, and poor Jillian was caught wearing them just a couple months ago on Project Runway. So if they’re so ridiculous why do people keep making them?

Read the rest of this entry »



Accessories, Designer Fashions, Yay or Nay

Yay or Nay Wednesday: Burberry Prorsum Harlech studded belt

By Andrea Kiliany Thatcher on March 19th, 2008

Burberry belt.jpg

Is it a medieval torture device or a belt? Depends how tight you cinch it we supposed.

The real question is: Yay or Nay?

To be fair we’ll show you what it looks like as part of an outfit after the jump.

Read the rest of this entry »



Accessories, Designer Fashions, Footwear, New Fashions, Yay or Nay

Yay or Nay Wednesday: Christian Louboutin cutout bootie

By Andrea Kiliany Thatcher on March 12th, 2008

Louboutin cutout bootie.jpg

For many of us, booties themselves were questionable enough. So what do you think of this Christian Louboutin cutout bootie, $860?

And furthermore, when you see a shoe or bag or any item that you’re not sure about – does it help sway you when it’s by a favorite designer?

Would you buy a shoe by Christian Louboutin that you would never buy from a less iconic designer? Why?



Accessories, Designer Fashions, Handbags, New Fashions, Yay or Nay

Yay or Nay Wednesday: Marc Jacobs mesh lace Robert bag on bags

By Andrea Thatcher on February 13th, 2008

Marc%20Jacobs%20bag%20on%20bag.jpg

Keris over at TheBagLady drew our attention to this Marc Jacobs bag-on-bag combo, $2,100. What do we think, yay or nay? I believe this raises a larger fashion philosophical question – does the fact that it’s Marc Jacobs ensure that it’s a yay? After his spring collection, some people are changing their tunes on that issue. What about you? Little purse sewed onto a big purse – yay or nay?



Accessories, Designer Fashions, Handbags, New Fashions, Retail News, Yay or Nay

Yay or Nay Wednesday: new Chloe bags

By Andrea Thatcher on January 30th, 2008

new%20chloe%20bags.jpg (Click image to enlarge.)

What do you think of the new Chloe bags just arrived at Net-a-Porter? Personally, these bags make me long for an Elvire or the days of the Paddington. From left to right we have the Ada tote, $2,280, the bay bag, a favorite of our UK sister TheBagLady at $1,780, and the Saskia leather tote, $,2005, my least favorite of the bunch. What do you think – yay or nay?

For more handbag news, go to www.thebaglady.tv.



Celebrity Style, Yay or Nay

Yay or Nay Wednesday: Mena Suvari at Sundance

By Andrea Thatcher on January 23rd, 2008

Mena%20Suvari%20Sundance.jpg

What do you think of Mena Suvari’s look in the famous photobooth at the Sundance Film Festival? We find it interesting to wear when you know you’re not only going to be shot by paparazzi, but are having your cast portraits taken that day (she’s in The Mysteries of Pittsburgh). I would probably warm up to the whole look, even if it is a bit tough, if only she weren’t wearing that head scarf. I think it’s aweful, but some have said it made the outfit. What do you think?




©2010 Shiny Digital Privacy Policy